Favorite Non-HOF Cardinal

This post is an idea I’ve come up with to generate some interest and commentary.

Basically, the idea is, write a comment that mentions you’re favorite Cardinal who’s not an MLB Hall Of Famer. (Ones in the Cardinals HOF are allowed.) One caveat: You cannot re-use a player someone else has already used. This’ll help add some variety. Current players are allowed.

Since it’s my blog, I’ll start. My choice is from the Whitey-Ball era. Willie McGee. One odd thing, until checking Willie’s stats I didn’t remember that he’d had a long career, spanning from 1982 until 1999, ending up with over 2200 hits and a .295 career average. Not bad for a guy who didn’t look like your typical player.

That’s what I remember about Willie, he didn’t *look* like a baseball player, he looked long and and skinny, was all arms and legs and had that long neck….If he looked like an athlete from any sport, it’d be basketball.

And yet, the man could hit. As I said above, he ended up with a .295 career average. His best season was in 1985 where he hit .353 with 10 homeruns, 82 RBI’s and 56 stolen bases, culminating in an MVP Award.

Willie had his share of other honors too. 4 all-star games, 3 Gold Gloves and one Silver Slugger from that ’85 season.

Some might argue that his high batting averages were a little empty, as he didn’t walk much, and while it’s true he never had a .400 OBP, not even in 1985, alot of players these days would happily take the .333 Career OBP Willie ended up with. And it’s true he didn’t hit for power either, but that wasn’t his game. His game was to get on and create a little havoc. The .295 average and 352 career steals attest to that.

But beyond the stats, what I’ll always remember is that tall, skinny guy who could hit. Being a tall, skinny guy myself, I admired him. He gave me hope, hope that not everyone needed to be muscular to  excel in baseball.

To this day, I admire guys like him, guys who don’t pass the eye test, or the flamethrower test. Guys like Jose Altuve of the Astros or Mark Buerhle of the Blue Jays. Give me the scrappers, the crafty veterans. You can keep your Trouts and Kershaws.

Well, there’s my guy, who’s yours?



2 thoughts on “Favorite Non-HOF Cardinal”

  1. Tough call, of course, but I’d probably say Scott Rolen. I really was excited when he came to St. Louis and hated the way his career ended here. Wish he’d be a part of the organization, though the Reds might have a stronger pull on him.


  2. Coming from one of the young guys, I’m very historically challenged. My favorite non-HOF Cardinal is Yadier Molina. He’ll make the hall, but right now he still fits your category. 😉


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s